An object found at the bottom of a lake may be investigators’ best chance of solving a brutal homicide. Episode Info Kim Montelaro Photo Courtesy of northjersey.com Kim Montelaro Photo Courtesy of northjersey.com Montelaro family (right) and Assemblyman Bob Schroeder (left) outside parole hearing for Righetti in 2009 Photo Courtesy of NJ.com Montelaro family (right) and Assemblyman Bob Schroeder (left) outside parole hearing for Righetti in 2009 Photo Courtesy of NJ.com Evidence photo of knife found on the lake bottom Photo Courtesy of the New Milford Police Department Evidence photo of knife found on the lake bottom Photo Courtesy of the New Milford Police Department Additional Source Material Youth Is Convicted Of Rape and Murder’ Of Bergen Woman ‘Loophole’ puts man convicted in 1976 rape-murder in Paramus up for parole for fifth time Advocates continue fight against parole for man convicted in 1976 Bergen County murder Man Who Murdered Woman He Kidnapped From Paramus Mall Up For Parole