In this small Indiana town, murders are rare, but rumors run rampant. A sheriff nearing retirement sifts through different leads in his final push to solve a 41-year-old case. Episode Info Sarah Jeanette Benson Photo Courtesy of WBIW News Sarah Jeanette Benson Photo Courtesy of WBIW News Sarah Jeanette Benson Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Sarah Jeanette Benson Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Sarah Jeanette Benson Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Sarah Jeanette Benson Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Crime Scene Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Crime Scene Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Crime Scene Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Crime Scene Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Crime Scene Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Crime Scene Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Crime Scene Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Crime Scene Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Crime Scene Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Crime Scene Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office Additional Source Material The Jeanette Benson Case: How You Could Help Solve a Murder Cold case: Police in Sullivan County seek leads in 1980s murder INVESTIGATORS SEEK ANSWERS IN SARAH “JEANETTE” BENSON MURDER Investigators continue to ask for public’s help in Sarah “Jeanette” Benson murder